Nut Butter Crazy Cookies

Jul 9, 2020 | Recipes, Sweet treats

Alright my gluten free followers. You all have a special space in my heart because I grew up with a gluten intolerant mama. So always looking for a way to please you all because I know how hard dessert eating is when you can’t have flour. The no flour peanut butter cookies that everyone uses is just too much sugar for me to justify, so I thought I could recreate a less sugary version, with absolutely no refined sugar. Another added bonus. I used a combo of maple syrup and coconut sugar here for two reasons. For one, I was looking for a super low glycemic index cookie and coconut sugar really accomplishes this. But when I did purely coconut sugar, my husband made too many faces. It tasted fine to my palate, so for all of you who have a sugar cleansed palette, I urge you to try the full coconut sugar version. But anyway, I added the maple syrup to up the sweetness a bit, though it obviously cost a bit in the GI arena. But secondly, this actually turned out to help the recipe because I do think the depth in flavor when it comes to caramelization of the sugars really works with this combo.

One last note before I reveal the recipe. Chocolate chips were also added to the recipe to subside my husbands faces. Lol. But in all honesty, if you are looking for a low carb, low sugar snack for mid weak pick me ups, it really doesn’t need the chocolate. Only an added bonus!

In terms of the nut butter brands I choose. When it comes to almond butter there is one brand and one brand only in Israel that consistently gives me amazing recipe results. Hashaked only! Virtually any health food chain should sell them. I haven’t developed any strong preferences in peanut butter brands, the key to most baking recipes is just that it’s a smooth consistency, and a bit more liquidy, which I find Israeli peanut butters to be consistent with. Since I haven’t found a specific brand, I just go for the ones on sale (the natural ones of course).

About Me

Hi! Thanks for stopping by! I’m Liat, a certified yoga instructor and dietician in training. My goal is to help you navigate healthy living here in Israel with recipes and tips that will show you just how doable healthy eating can be without sacrificing the dishes that you love! Happy navigating fellow fresh sabras xoxo

Nut Butter Crazy Cookies

Servings: two dozen small cookies

1 ¼ cup almond butter
2 eggs
½ tsp baking soda
½ tsp cinnamon
3 tbsp coconut sugar
3 tbsp maple syrup
½ tsp vanilla extract
Optional: 1/3 cup chocolate chips


1. Preheat the over to 180°c and line 2 cookies sheets with parchment paper
2. Combine the nut butter and eggs and stir till the eggs are fully incorporated
3. Whisk in the remaining ingredients until combined. The batter will be pretty thick and hard to manipulate. I like to grease my hands with a bit of oil of choice to make sure the batter doesn’t stick to my hands as I form the cookies.
4. Shape the batter into 20 small balls, ensuring there is a bit of space between each cookie.
5. Bake in the preheated oven for 8-10 minutes or until the edges begin to brown
6. Cool on the baking sheet completely before removing
7. Can be kept in the freezer up to 2 months

You might also like…

Twenty Minute Sticky Beef

Twenty Minute Sticky Beef

Anything 20 minute is going to be key over the next little bit. This one is a staple in our house. It's quick and easy, and forgiving. And even though it only takes 15 + minutes of active cooking time, the flavor is NOT lacking in the slightest. Also it gets in...

read more
Chicken Soup for the Soul

Chicken Soup for the Soul

AKA as the best chicken soup. You must give it a try! Not even joking, I am known as the chicken soup lady in every community I have lived in thus far. Wanna know the secret? You'll have to keep reading for that one. I was trying to get really creative for this one...

read more